Where was the first Legislative Assembly held, known as the birthplace of democracy in Cayman?

The first Legislative Assembly of the Cayman Islands was held at Pedro St. James, which is often referred to as the birthplace of democracy in the region. This historic site, constructed in the late 18th century, served as an important political and social venue. The decision to hold the assembly there signifies its central role in the governance and democratic development of the Cayman Islands. The choice of Pedro St. James helped establish a foundation for democratic practices in the territory, making it a significant landmark in Caymanian history.

The other locations mentioned do not hold the same historical significance related to the first Legislative Assembly and the development of democracy in the Cayman Islands. This context reinforces why Pedro St. James is recognized as the correct answer.